Is Poland’s Flexible Staffing Ready for the Discipline Europe’s Largest Employer Applied?

veritahr.com 2 godzin temu

The latest government figures paint a troubling picture of Poland’s labour market. Foreign workers are helping plug the gaps but should they depart, the country could find itself facing the full force of its demographic decline. That makes the recent staffing overhaul at the NHS, Europe’s largest employer, particularly worth watching. Its efforts offer Poland a potential blueprint, but one that would demand a major shake-up of its flexible staffing market.

Poland’s Demographic Squeeze

A November study, commissioned by Poland’s Ministry of Family, Labour and Social Policy, identified 14 occupations facing nationwide shortages in 2027. These include doctors, nurses, teachers, professional drivers, warehouse workers, electricians and welders. Notably, no occupation is classified as having a surplus.

The longer-term arithmetic is equally dour. The Polish Economic Institute projects that the number of people in work could fall by around 2.1 million by 2035, a 12.6 per cent decline in overall employment. This would put Poland among the sharpest contractions in Central and Eastern Europe, outpacing most larger Western European economies. A similar decline in industrial employment alone could reduce GDP by as much as 8 per cent.

Poland Total Labour Force
Chart shape recreated from the supplied screenshot. For exact annual values, use the linked World Bank series.

Much of this pressure has so far been offset by the influx of Ukrainian workers, who now account for around two-thirds of Poland’s foreign workforce and roughly 5 per cent of total employment. But this dependence comes with its own vulnerabilities. If national averages are to be applied, around 300,000 Ukrainians may be working exclusively on civil-law contracts, colloquially known as junk contracts, which sit outside standard Labour Code protections and can leave workers more exposed to exploitation.

If the war ends and Poland fails to retain a substantial share of this workforce, it could lose one of its biggest buffers against labour shortages just as demographic pressures intensify. It is a challenge the NHS, Europe’s largest employer, has already had to confront.

How the NHS Reduced Agency Dependence

The UK’s National Health Service (NHS) makes an interesting comparison. Despite operating in a very different labour market, it has been grappling with many of the same problems. With around 1.4 million full-time employees, it ranks among the world’s largest employers, alongside the US Department of Defense and China’s People’s Liberation Army.

For years, the NHS has relied heavily on overseas recruitment and temporary agency workers to keep services running. Both have become increasingly difficult to sustain. Nursing and Midwifery Council figures show that internationally educated professionals joining its register fell by almost a third between 2024 and 2025. The number of overseas-trained nurses and midwives joining between April and September 2025 was also down by around 50 per cent year on year.

Agency staffing, meanwhile, had become a major financial headache. NHS trusts spent approximately £3 billion on agency workers in 2023–24, often paying substantial premiums to external providers to fill shifts that could potentially have been covered by their existing workforce. With agency margins adding to an already considerable wage bill, the cost of temporary staffing was becoming increasingly difficult to justify. The NHS needed flexibility to keep services running, but the way it was buying that flexibility was proving unsustainable. This prompted a more coordinated response.

From November 2024, the NHS began tightening controls on agency staffing, setting trusts a target of cutting agency expenditure by at least 30 per cent. The results were significant, with spending falling from £2.1 billion in 2024/25 to approximately £1.2 billion in 2025/26, a reduction of 43 per cent.

Public sector workforce · United Kingdom

NHS Agency Staff Expenditure

Financial years 2022/23–2025/26 · £ billions

Source: NHS Financial Performance Reports 2022–2026 · NHS England – Financial Performance Reports

A major part of this shift has been the expansion of staff banks, which involve internal pools of employees willing to take on additional shifts. NHS England reinforced this approach with dedicated guidance, encouraging trusts to develop shared banks across regional health systems. Some already report strong results, with Rotherham NHS Foundation Trust announcing savings of around £500,000 in agency costs.

The NHS is also looking to reduce its reliance on overseas recruitment. The government’s 10-Year Health Plan aims to bring international recruitment below 10 per cent by 2035, placing greater emphasis on domestic training and retention. The intention is not to exclude overseas workers, but to make the health service less dependent on a continuous supply of recruits from abroad.

Of course, this is not to suggest that the NHS has suddenly solved its perennial workforce problems. Nor can Poland simply transplant this model into its own labour market. Nevertheless, the comparison highlights that missing coordinated effort in Poland to make flexible staffing more sustainable. Poland’s Ministry of Family, Labour and Social Policy maintains a registration system for employment agencies and can remove entities that no longer meet the requirements. There are also statutory protections governing temporary employment. Yet these measures do not amount to a national strategy for managing the sector’s dependence on external labour or improving contractual standards.

Fragmentation and Oversight Gaps

Industry organisations such as the Polish HR Forum (PFHR) and the Association of Employment Agencies (SAZ) help fill part of that gap. SAZ represents more than 50 companies, while PFHR’s reporting covers 32 capital groups comprising 73 companies, including many of Poland’s largest HR providers. Yet even these established organisations have limited reach in a market containing over 8,286 registered agencies. Both the scale and constant churn of the markets make oversight a considerable challenge, particularly when 1,756 agencies were removed from the register in 2025 alone, against 1,493 new registrations.

The State Labour Inspectorate‘s findings offer a clue on what this fragmentation can mean in practice. Its 2025 inspections identified irregularities in 95.8 per cent of the 191 temporary employment agencies examined. Problems included the improper use of civil-law contracts, unpaid employment benefits, failures involving medical examinations and breaches of temporary work regulations. This does not mean that virtually every Polish agency is breaking the law, but the frequency uncovered is difficult to dismiss.

There is also a striking divide between established providers and the wider market when it comes to employment conditions. PFHR data show that 82 per cent of temporary workers employed through its member agencies have standard employment contracts. Across the wider market, the figure is just 38 per cent. That difference is particularly important for foreign workers, who often depend on agencies to find employment in Poland. The type of contract they receive can determine their access to paid leave, sickness benefits and greater employment security. If Poland wants to remain attractive to international workers, improving those conditions will need to become part of the conversation about how its flexible staffing market develops.

The answer is not to eliminate civil-law contracts or restrict temporary staffing, both of which have a legitimate role in industries with fluctuating workloads. Rather, Poland needs to make the market more accountable through stronger enforcement, better cooperation between industry organisations and greater use of internal staffing pools.

With millions fewer people potentially available for work over the coming decade, Poland cannot afford to let one of its most useful recruitment tools become a source of further labour-market instability. The NHS has shown that coordinated workforce management can make a measurable difference. Poland now needs to decide whether it is prepared to apply the same discipline to its own staffing market.

Verita HR works with firms on permanent recruitment and outsourcing for technology and specialist engineering roles in Poland. In a labour market already under pressure from demographic decline and heavy reliance on flexible staffing, we help employers map compensation benchmarks, realistic hiring timelines and the profiles most likely to deliver stable, long-term results.

Verita HR offers services including RPO | Permanent Recruitment | Outsourcing | Media Services

Author: Michal Pawlak

Idź do oryginalnego materiału